bloooooooom Eight o's. Don't count, bookmark. Plan a bed

New York aster

Symphyotrichum novi-belgii · Asteraceae

New York aster (Symphyotrichum novi-belgii) in flower
Photo: maureen_c-m, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

The Michaelmas daisy of English borders: masses of daisies in purple, blue, pink or white in early autumn, on smooth-leaved plants from dwarf to tall.

Size
3 ft tall, 24 in wide
Zones
4 to 8
Light
Full sun
Flowers
Late August to mid October
Pets
No toxicity recorded
Job in a bed
Drift

A bed built around New York aster

The planner designed this bed around New York aster when this page was made: a 12 × 6 ft (3.7 × 1.8 m) naturalistic planting in zone 6, full sun. It chose the other plants from the 966 that suit those conditions, and says below why New York aster stands where it does.

A 12 × 6 ft (3.7 × 1.8 m) bed at eye level in mid September: New York aster, Lingonberry, Creeping phlox 'Emerald Blue', Garden phlox 'David', Silver sage, Quaking grass, Star of Persia, Schubert's allium.
A 12 × 6 ft (3.7 × 1.8 m) naturalistic planting in zone 6, full sun, seen from the path in mid September.
4. Garden phlox 'David'44. Garden phlox 'David'44. Garden phlox 'David'41. New York aster11. New York aster11. New York aster15. Silver sage53. Creeping phlox 'Emerald Blue'33. Creeping phlox 'Emerald Blue'33. Creeping phlox 'Emerald Blue'32. Lingonberry22. Lingonberry22. Lingonberry22. Lingonberry26. Quaking grass66. Quaking grass66. Quaking grass66. Quaking grass66. Quaking grass66. Quaking grass68. Schubert's allium88. Schubert's allium88. Schubert's allium87. Star of Persia77. Star of Persia77. Star of Persia72. Lingonberry22. Lingonberry22. Lingonberry2
From above, to scale. Each circle is one plant, as wide as the room it needs.

The plants

  1. 2 Lingonberry × 7, pink
  2. 3 Creeping phlox 'Emerald Blue' × 3, blue
  3. 4 Garden phlox 'David' × 3, white
  4. 5 Silver sage × 1, silver leaves
  5. 6 Quaking grass × 6, tan
  6. 7 Star of Persia × 3, purple
  7. 8 Schubert's allium × 3, pink

Why this plant

  • The only daisies. The others are bells, open bowls, dense clusters and others. Shape reads at a distance, where colours blur.

Why here

  • Anchors a back corner. At 3 ft it is one of the taller plants here, and the tallest close the ends of the bed, where they stand in front of nothing.
  • A step in the back row. Next to quaking grass (24 in): no two neighbours there are the same height, so the back steps up and down like a skyline.
  • 3 plants in one group. Massed, one kind reads as a single shape. Scattered, it would look spotty.

Why now

  • In flower for 7 weeks. From late August to mid October.
  • Closes the season. For its last five weeks nothing else on the plan is in flower.

Planned as a naturalistic planting: low grasses and groundcovers, the matrix, make up 52% of the planted ground. The flowering is at its height from late May, with 4 kinds out together. The flowers stay on the cool side of the palette: purple, pink, blue, white and tan.

The planner's own design check: 10 Excellent, 6 Good, 1 Satisfactory. It flags one thing to watch: Nothing on this plan is highly poisonous or an aggressive spreader.

Open this bed in the planner Change its size, the sun or the style, move plants about, or swap one for another.

Where New York aster goes in a border

At 3 ft it belongs in the middle of a bed. In the planner's ten height classes it is medium tall (2½ to 3 ft).

Its job: drift. Planted in a small group of three or five, and repeated further along in the other number.

The widest colour range of any aster. It needs moist soil and division every two or three years to stay healthy, and is prone to mildew when dry.

  • Autumn colour in the border
  • Cut flowers
  • Late nectar for butterflies

What to plant with New York aster

Plants recorded as good partners for it, and what each pairing does:

  • Goldenrod 'Fireworks': purple against yellow, opposite each other on the colour wheel, if you choose those colours, in flower together for seven weeks.
  • Switchgrass 'Shenandoah': its green leaves are a setting for the flowers, before and after.
  • Sneezeweed: purple against yellow, opposite each other on the colour wheel, if you choose those colours, in flower together for five weeks; happy in the same moist soil.

Questions about New York aster

Does New York aster need sun or shade?

New York aster grows in full sun (6 or more hours of direct sun a day).

It wants soil that stays evenly moist, of average fertility, and a good soak in dry spells.

What zones does New York aster grow in?

USDA zones 4 to 8. It is hardy to zone 4, which means it survives winter nights down to about −20 °F (−29 °C).

Above zone 8 it struggles: the zones measure winter cold, but a plant's top zone usually means the summers are too hot or the winters too mild for it to rest.

Gardening in Canada? Use the USDA zone for your town: Canada's own zone map uses different numbers.

When does New York aster flower in my zone?

In zone 5 it flowers late August to mid October. As a summer flower it moves about half a week for every zone: earlier where it is warmer.

Roughly when New York aster is in flower
Zone 4Early September to mid October
Zone 5Late August to mid October
Zone 6Late August to mid October
Zone 7Late August to mid October
Zone 8Late August to mid October

Worked out from Hopkins' bioclimatic law: spring arrives about four days later for each degree of latitude north, and one zone is roughly two degrees. A warm spring or a cold one moves any garden two weeks either way.

How far apart should New York aster be planted?

24 in (60 cm) apart, from the middle of one plant to the middle of the next. That is about its full width, so each plant keeps its own outline.

It grows 3 ft (90 cm) tall. Give it the full distance from anything taller, or it will lean out towards the light.

How many New York aster plants do I need?

At 24 in apart, set out in staggered rows:

  • 3 to fill 10 square feet (about 1 m²)
  • 6 for a single row 10 ft (3 m) long
  • 10 to fill a 4 × 8 ft bed on its own

In a mixed border, plant it as a group of three or five, with a second group further along in the other number.

In the bed above, the planner used three in one group.

Is New York aster poisonous to dogs and cats?

No toxicity is recorded for dogs, cats, horses or people, according to NC State Extension.

"Not toxic" is not "edible": a pet that eats a lot of any plant can be sick.

Do deer eat New York aster?

Mostly not. NC State lists it as resistant to deer. No plant is proof against a hungry deer in a hard winter, but this one is low on the menu.

Will New York aster spread?

It spreads sideways, by runners or roots; the risk of it taking over is moderate. Spreads by underground runners and can crowd its neighbours. Dig out the edges or divide every 2 to 3 years.

What flowers after New York aster?

New York aster is over by mid October. These start as it finishes and carry the same spot on, so it never goes flat:

What does New York aster look like in winter?

New York aster dies down, but leave the stems standing: the seed heads stand through the winter, and songbirds eat the seed. Cut them down in early spring, before the new shoots come.

Is New York aster good for bees and butterflies?

New York aster is visited by pollinators, bees, specialist bees, butterflies and songbirds.

It is a host plant: the caterpillars of pearl crescent feed on its leaves. A butterfly can only lay its eggs on its host plants, so these do more for it than any nectar flower.

It is native to the United States and Canada.

More Symphyotrichum

In these guides

Zone guides: Zone 4 · Zone 5 · Zone 6 · Zone 7 · Zone 8

In flower in: August · September · October

Every fact on record

Type
Perennial
Size
3 ft (90 cm) tall, 24 in (60 cm) wide
Plant
24 in (60 cm) apart
Height class
Medium tall (2½ to 3 ft)
Place in the bed
Middle
Flowers
Late August to mid October; daisies; purple, blue, pink, white
Leaves
Medium texture, herbaceous; dark green
Shape
Upright, spreading
Hardy in
USDA zones 4 to 8
Light
Full sun
Soil
Average, evenly moist
Water
Moderate
Feeding
Light, in spring
Family
Asteraceae
Comes from
E. Canada to NE. U.S.A
Attracts
Pollinators, bees, specialist bees, butterflies, songbirds
Host plant for
Pearl crescent
Stands up to
Deer

Checked against NC State Extension. Flowering times are for zone 5: later in colder zones, earlier in warmer ones. Toxicity and spread information is a general gardening guide, not veterinary or medical advice, and invasive status varies by region. If a person or pet eats a plant, contact poison control or a vet. Check your local invasive species list before planting anything with a spread warning.